Radical subcultures and mobilisation
any follow-up questions on this? (full review in late January)
subculture - a cultural group within a larger culture with its own traits, beliefs, and interests, typically distinct from and sometimes at odds with the larger culture
So this evolution has created a subculture: music, clothing (e.g., shoelaces), political beliefs and orientation
1960s: ‘mod’ subculture in UK (working class youth with upward social mobility, stylish clothes, American soul & Jamaican ska)
1970s: skinhead aesthetic, ‘street punk’/Oi! music
A short documentary about the Rechtsrock concert in Ostritz in 2019:
But no alcohol allowed… (see further in Spiegel article)
Given the context of the other events and the resulting encounter between the various political camps, as well as the obviously combative and aggressive nature of the event, alcohol consumption would undoubtedly further increase the risk of violent clashes.
Vor dem Hintergrund der weiteren Veranstaltungen und der damit einhergehenden Begegnung der verschiedenen politischen Lager sowie des offensichtlich kämpferisch-aggressiven Charakters der Veranstaltung würde ein Alkoholkonsum unzweifelhaft die Gefahr von gewaltsamen Auseinandersetzungen weiter erhöhen.
Data download (English)
Data download (German)
Why are these two codes connected?
Is the connection meaningful?
This visualisation is drawn from ‘Fashion against Fascism’ project of the ‘Laut gegen Nazis’ association. As part of the association’s goal to stymie right-wing extremist activity (particularly in Germany), they support efforts to trademark certain symbols and codes, intending to prevent right-wing extremists from using them on merchandise, etc.. This denies them an important source of financing.
The network shows similarities in code descriptions in the dataset. (Term Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency: statistical measure of the importance of a word in a document relative to a corpus.) Each code is a node; nodes are coloured based on a quick categorisation; larger nodes have more connections; connections represent textual similarity (just based on the ‘Description’) between two codes.
Any subculture examples you know? Any overlap with extremist groups? What are the distinguishing characteristics? Certain clothing, music, symbols, practices?
More than 1000 people from the Balkan region travelled between 2012 and 2016 to become foreign fighters (Azinović & Bećirević 2017), a disproportionately high number.
Our cases represent two of the most influential armed groups in Europe, among the few who lasted for more than 10 years, with a broad territorial coverage and a relatively high number of members and sympathizers. They differ however in their main ideological roots: ethnonationalist for the PIRA, socio-revolutionary for the BR.
some methodological points: scope for generalisation
some methodological points: scope for generalisation
Although our empirical testing concerns PIRA and BR armed activists, we believe that similar micromobilization paths can be found in other armed groups. This is true if we think of the works of Jocelyan Viterna (2006) on the women’s mobilization into the FMLN in El Savador, that of Fernando Reinares (2001) with ETA militants, Olivier Roy’s(2004) work with Islamic militants mobilization into Al Qaeda in the Middle East, or the work of Gilda Zwerman and Patricia Steinhoff (2005) regarding left-wing armed groups in the US and Japan in the post 1960s.
| Path | Dominant motivations (micro level) | Recruitment- relevant networks (meso level) | Perception of context (macro level) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ideological | Ideological, identity | Family and territorial traditions | Potential revolutionary situation |
| Instrumental | Aspiration to change | Political groups | Closed opportunities |
| Solidaristic | Experiential cognition | Peer group | Escalation of political conflict |
(generalizability): Are the described pathways fitting for less violent groups with more limited goals which never included an attack on the state or the status quo? Can the 3 types be used to analyse counterrevolutionary terrorism?
| Path | Dominant motivations | Recruitment- relevant networks | Perception of context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ideological | Ideological, identity | Family and territorial traditions | Potential revolutionary situation |
| Instrumental | Aspiration to change | Political groups | Closed opportunities |
| Solidaristic | Experiential cognition | Peer group | Escalation of political conflict |
“We were all trusted comrades: we had known each other for a long time and were very good friends” (Alberto Franceschini, quoted in Fasanella and Franceschini 2004, 44). In other words, in their initial phases both armed groups exploited pre-existing social and affective ties in recruitment processes in order to avoid possible infiltrations. While in the Northern Ireland case the family was also relevant in recruitment to the armed group (e.g. interviewees 1, 6, 11 and 17), in the Italian case the family remained more important as a cultural symbol, and joining the BR was perceived as a rupture with the family environment
examples of this path from extremist group cases?
many activists joined armed groups after a long search for effective strategies to achieve their political aims (Interviewees 2, 5, 18, 19, 20 for the PIRA and Balzerani, Fiore, Peci, Ronconi and Interviewees 26 and 27 for the BR). They usually joined armed groups later in life following dissatisfaction with the “ordinary” politics in which they were involved. They judged armed groups according to whether or not they had the capacity to stage successful campaigns and lead to concrete results.
examples of this path from extremist group cases?
The context in which these individuals mobilized was in fact one of escalation. For many individuals the armed struggle was a way to cope with societies which seemed to them in turmoil. High repression and counter-movement violence in collaboration with the establishment worked for young individuals as a loss of innocence, which further delegitimized the regimes and justified their mobilization in the PIRA and the BR. … The leadership of the PIRA had, for example, planned to provoke street disturbances with the deliberate intention of producing an outward spiral of violence, knowing full well the benefits the British Army repression would reap in terms of support and recruits from the nationalist community.
examples of this path from extremist group cases?
Take the survey at https://forms.gle/oUEhq9W19sBD4E9R9
Questions about groups: (1) Does a distinct subculture exist around this group? (2) Did participation in the group’s social scene (events, meeting places, online spaces, music, symbols, etc.) was an important step toward deeper involvement? (3) Is the group’s subculture primarily in-person, online, or mixed? (4) Are most people were likely recruited through pre-existing social ties (e.g., friends, family, classmates)? (5) What do you think was the single most important factor in mobilisation for your group?
import { liveGoogleSheet } from "@jimjamslam/live-google-sheet";
import { aq, op } from "@uwdata/arquero";
// UPDATE THE LINK FOR A NEW POLL
surveyResults = liveGoogleSheet(
"https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/" +
"2PACX-1vSSwGAaIviE0BRA9cn-hLDew4_L7tv8HiR9meT_nuRaShGInM75Eeg6pmR6ttTx5QAiJltUL3AHi7OM/" +
"pub?gid=1280605096&single=true&output=csv",
10000, 1, 7); // adjust the last number to select all relevant columns
respondentCount = surveyResults.length;
likertOrder = [
"Strongly disagree",
"Disagree",
"Neutral",
"Agree",
"Strongly agree"
];
ynmOrder = [
"Yes",
"No",
"Maybe"
];
groupOrder = [
"Antifa",
"RAF",
"IS",
"alQaeda",
"NPD/Heimat",
"NSU",
"PKK"
];
groupColors = [
"pink",
"red",
"grey",
"black",
"#d2b48c", // lightbrown - could also use 'peru'
"brown",
"green"
];Group has a distinct subculture?
g_distinct_subcultureCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_distinct_subculture", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_distinct_subculture = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_distinct_subcultureCounts, {
fx: "g_distinct_subculture",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: ynmOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: 0
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});Subculture is primarily…
g_subculture_primarilyCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_subculture_primarily", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_subculture_primarily = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_subculture_primarilyCounts, {
fx: "g_subculture_primarily",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
// domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -45
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});Being in group’s social scene precedes membership
g_social_participationCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_social_participation", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_social_participation = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_social_participationCounts, {
fx: "g_social_participation",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -55
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});Most recruited through existing social ties.
g_most_recruitmentCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_most_recruitment", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_most_recruitment = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_most_recruitmentCounts, {
fx: "g_most_recruitment",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -55
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});single most important factor in mobilisation for the group?
g_most_important_factorCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_most_important_factor", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_most_important_factor = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_most_important_factorCounts, {
fx: "g_most_important_factor",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
// domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -45
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});Recruitment and Organisational Involvement (PIRUS)
This visualisation is based on a subset of the Profiles of Individual Radicalization in the United States (PIRUS) dataset. It compares levels of organisational involvement with recruitment experiences and highlights the role of group environments in processes of radicalisation and mobilisation.
National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START), University of Maryland. (2024). Profiles of Individual Radicalization in the United States (PIRUS) [Data file]. Retrieved from http://www.start.umd.edu/data-tools/profiles-individual-radicalization-united-states-pirus. Copyright University of Maryland 2024.
pirus = FileAttachment("../resources/data/PIRUS_February_2025/PIRUS_plot_data.csv")
.csv({typed: true})
.then(data => data.filter(d => d.Year_Exposure >= 1990))
//pirus = FileAttachment("PIRUS_plot_data.csv").csv({typed: true})viewof vars = Inputs.checkbox(
["Role_Group", "Actively_Recruited"],
{
label: "Vars.",
value: ["Role_Group"]
}
)
plotData = pirus.filter(d => vars.includes(d.Variable))
plotData2 = plotData.map(d => ({
...d,
Group: d.Variable === "Role_Group" ? "Role" : "Recruit"
}))
Plot.plot({
width: 1800,
height: 800,
marginBottom: 100,
marginLeft: 80,
style: { fontSize: "30px" },
x: {
label: "",
tickRotate: -90,
tickFormat: d => String(d)
},
y: {
label: "Count",
grid: true
},
color: {
legend: true,
legendFontSize: 30,
domain: [
"Associate",
"Follower",
"Leader",
"NoGroup",
"Recruited",
"NotRecruited",
"Unknown"
],
range: [
"#1b9e77",
"#d95f02",
"#7570b3",
"#666666",
"#e7298a",
"#66a61e",
"#cccccc"
]
},
marks: [
Plot.barY(
plotData2,
Plot.stackY({
x: "Year_Exposure",
y: "N",
fill: "Category",
fx: "Group", // This creates the side-by-side dodge
tip: true,
title: d => `${d.Year_Exposure}\n${d.Group}\n${d.Category}\nN = ${d.N}`
})
)
]
})This visualisation is based on a subset of the Profiles of Individual Radicalization in the United States (PIRUS) dataset. The bar charts show distributions of group roles and recruitment patterns over time.
National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START), University of Maryland. (2024). Profiles of Individual Radicalization in the United States (PIRUS) [Data file]. Retrieved from http://www.start.umd.edu/data-tools/profiles-individual-radicalization-united-states-pirus. Copyright University of Maryland 2024.
Data download
This visualisation is based on a subset of the Profiles of Individual Radicalization in the United States (PIRUS) dataset. It plots the primary location of radicalised individuals and the bubble reflect their role within groups
compares the number of individuals associated with different ideological categories, including Islamist, White Supremacist, Militia, Anarchist, and Anti-Capitalist movements. The data cover cases recorded between 1948 and 2022 and provide an overview of the ideological diversity represented within the PIRUS database. This allows us to compare the relative prevalence of different ideological backgrounds among radicalised individuals included in the dataset.
National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START), University of Maryland. (2024). Profiles of Individual Radicalization in the United States (PIRUS) [Data file]. Retrieved from http://www.start.umd.edu/data-tools/profiles-individual-radicalization-united-states-pirus. Copyright University of Maryland 2024.
Data download
Anonymous feedback here: https://forms.gle/NfF1pCfYMbkAT3WP6
Alternatively, please send me an email: m.zeller@lmu.de
Questions about groups next meeting: (1) Did the group rely on centralised leadership? (2) Is group leadership based on formal hierarchy (i.e., not informal influence or reputation)? (3) Is the group’s network resilient to arrests or leadership loss? (4) How would you describe the group’s organisation?