Foreign fighters and political violence in authoritarian contexts
foreign fighters - individuals who travel to a conflict zone from another territory (prima facie evidence of radicalism \(\rightarrow\) engagement in political violence; a ‘security failure’ by authority of origin state?)
examples historically? from cases you know of?
foreign fighters - individuals who travel to a conflict zone from another territory (prima facie evidence of radicalism \(\rightarrow\) engagement in political violence; a ‘security failure’ by authority of origin state?)
examples historically? from cases you know of?
FF is a widespread part and enduring element of political violence across the world
Take the survey at https://forms.gle/JJ7ufLwrLJYKAbvg8
Questions about groups: (1) Did the group emerge in response to political repression? (2) Did the absence of (opportunity for) peaceful political participation contribute to the group’s use of violence? (3) Did the group actively recruit members from outside its primary country of operation? (4) How important were cross-border networks to this group’s activities? (5) Was the group’s cause was framed as an international struggle?
import { liveGoogleSheet } from "@jimjamslam/live-google-sheet";
import { aq, op } from "@uwdata/arquero";
// UPDATE THE LINK FOR A NEW POLL
surveyResults = liveGoogleSheet(
"https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/" +
"2PACX-1vTCOL_6dhwjrpQW9BGa1-p-uRlIknFTjWEkgBgHyaML3dziFgSxIgMU1pUmTfxJyHHm27Jv4_ZZUYT3/" +
"pub?gid=164736256&single=true&output=csv",
10000, 1, 12); // adjust the last number to select all relevant columns
respondentCount = surveyResults.length;
likertOrder = [
"Strongly disagree",
"Disagree",
"Neutral",
"Agree",
"Strongly agree"
];
ynmOrder = [
"Yes",
"No",
"Maybe"
];
groupOrder = [
"Antifa",
"RAF",
"IS",
"alQaeda",
"NPD/Heimat",
"NSU",
"PKK"
];
groupColors = [
"pink",
"red",
"grey",
"black",
"#d2b48c", // lightbrown - could also use 'peru'
"brown",
"green"
];group emerged in response to repression?
g_emerge_after_repressCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_emerge_after_repress", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_emerge_after_repress = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_emerge_after_repressCounts, {
fx: "g_emerge_after_repress",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: ynmOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: 0
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});lack of peaceful participation led to group’s use of violence
g_absence_of_peaceful_partCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_absence_of_peaceful_part", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_absence_of_peaceful_part = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_absence_of_peaceful_partCounts, {
fx: "g_absence_of_peaceful_part",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -55
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});group recruited from outside primary country?
g_recruit_outsideCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_recruit_outside", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_recruit_outside = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_recruit_outsideCounts, {
fx: "g_recruit_outside",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: ynmOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: 0
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});cross-border networks importance?
g_crossborder_netzCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_crossborder_netz", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_crossborder_netz = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_crossborder_netzCounts, {
fx: "g_crossborder_netz",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
// domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -45
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});group’s cause framed as an international struggle rather than local?
g_international_struggleCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("g_international_struggle", "group")
.count()
.objects();
plot_g_international_struggle = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(g_international_struggleCounts, {
fx: "g_international_struggle",
x: "group",
y: "count",
fill: "group",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: groupOrder,
range: groupColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -55
},
x: {
domain: groupOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});MENA (Middle East, North Africa) countries have sent the largest numbers of foreign fighters to Syria
MENA (Middle East, North Africa) countries have sent the largest numbers of foreign fighters to Syria
Major centres: Tangier, Tetouan, and surrounding region, and Fes; Cairo, Alexandria, and lower Nile area; Istanbul and Antep
any visualisation problems?
Remember: regression is a tool for understanding a phenomenon as a linear function (generally) → (y = mx + b)
Numbers not in parentheses next to a variable: regression coefficient: expected change in DV for a one-unit increase in IV. NB: ositive or negative relationship?
Numbers inside parentheses next to a variable: standard error: estimate of the standard deviation of the coefficient
Asterisks/‘stars’: statistical significance: probability of results as extreme as observed result, under the assumption that the null hypothesis is correct. Smaller p-value means such an observation would be less likely under null hypothesis; hence, significance. Statistical significance suggests more precise estimates—NOT necessarily that one IV is more important than another.
a university education is the strongest correlate of joining a terrorist organization.
Despite the difference in space and time, ISIS foreign fighters have a similar profile to members of Hamas, Hezbollah, the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, and even violent political activists in Bengal. The men in all these samples are predominately male, well-educated, urban, unmarried, and young.
a university education is the strongest correlate of joining a terrorist organization.
laws banning travel to conflict zones?
banning_travelCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.select("banning_travel")
.groupby("banning_travel")
.count()
.derive({ measure: d => "" })
// Calculate the maximum count from your dataset
banning_travel_maxCountRE = Math.max(...banning_travelCounts.objects().map(d => d.count));
plot_banning_travel = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.barY(banning_travelCounts, {
x: "banning_travel",
y: "count",
fill: "banning_travel",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.ruleY([respondentCount], { stroke: "#ffffff99" })
],
color: {
domain: [
"Yes",
"No",
"Maybe"
],
range: [
"forestgreen",
"darkred",
"goldenrod"
]
},
marginBottom: 80,
x: { label: "", tickSize: 2, tickRotate: -1, padding: 0.2,
domain: ["Yes", "No", "Maybe"]
},
y: {
label: "",
tickSize: 10,
tickFormat: d => d,
tickValues: Array.from(
new Set(banning_travelCounts.objects().map(d => d.count))
).sort((a, b) => a - b),
domain: [0, banning_travel_maxCountRE]
},
facet: { data: banning_travelCounts, x: "measure", label: "" },
marginLeft: 60,
style: {
width: 1600,
height: 500,
fontSize: 40,
},
});most effective for addressing foreign fighters phenomenon?
effective_addressingCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.select("effective_addressing")
.groupby("effective_addressing")
.count()
.derive({ measure: d => "" })
// Calculate the maximum count from your dataset
effective_addressing_maxCountRE = Math.max(...effective_addressingCounts.objects().map(d => d.count));
plot_effective_addressing = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.barY(effective_addressingCounts, {
x: "effective_addressing",
y: "count",
fill: "effective_addressing",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.ruleY([respondentCount], { stroke: "#ffffff99" })
],
color: {
domain: [
"border security",
"social work programmes",
"block recruitment/propaganda",
"other"
],
range: [
"darkred",
"goldenrod",
"cadetblue",
"gray"
]
},
marginBottom: 400,
x: { label: "", tickSize: 2, tickRotate: -40, padding: 0.2,
domain: ["border security", "social work programmes", "block recruitment/propaganda", "other"]
},
y: {
label: "",
tickSize: 10,
tickFormat: d => d,
tickValues: Array.from(
new Set(effective_addressingCounts.objects().map(d => d.count))
).sort((a, b) => a - b),
domain: [0, effective_addressing_maxCountRE]
},
facet: { data: effective_addressingCounts, x: "measure", label: "" },
marginLeft: 60,
style: {
width: 1600,
height: 500,
fontSize: 40,
},
});Spain example
Economist (a bit sensationalist and some graphic imagery)
David Malet