Collective identity and emotions
| Date | Presenters | Method |
|---|---|---|
any follow-up questions on this? (full review in late January)
any follow-up questions on this?
difference between bureaucratic organisations and grassroots radical organisations – one common org. type distinction
Exclusive affiliations:
Multiple affiliations:
any follow-up questions on this?
‘creation of strong identity can lead to backlash’ \(\rightarrow\) countering identities with different symbols, rituals, beliefs, etc.
(we will return to this in Class 10 on counter-mobilisation)
Is collective identity a ‘process’ or a ‘product’? (What about in cases you know of?)
anyone know what’s going on here?
Activists may define their identities in different ways depending on the strategic situation. If they are representing their group to a public audience, they may cast themselves as more unified and more homogeneous than they would in a setting of fellow activists.
common elements of collective identity among PEGIDA participants?
The data is the event-level version of PEGPAD (from Vullers & Hellmeier 2022, “Does counter-mobilization contain right-wing populist movements? Evidence from Germany”, European Journal of Political Research 61: 21-45). The dygraph plots total monthly events as the filled black line, with the two sides as coloured bars.
Data download

Take the survey at https://forms.gle/TY9iAYvw4KXvuMZMA
Questions about your movements:
import { liveGoogleSheet } from "@jimjamslam/live-google-sheet";
import { aq, op } from "@uwdata/arquero";
// UPDATE THE LINK FOR A NEW POLL
surveyResults = liveGoogleSheet(
"https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/" +
"2PACX-1vQhGEBN4WBNDu4Q5J_sP5aRblp46wM5WgXnG-a7w4ZrfKFPwQeZku_iheBsU6ga2YEdEXnNohZOE_7s/" +
"pub?gid=1282968597&single=true&output=csv",
10000, 1, 7); // adjust the last number to select all relevant columns
respondentCount = surveyResults.length;
likertOrder = [
"Strongly disagree",
"Disagree",
"Neutral",
"Agree",
"Strongly agree"
];
ynmOrder = [
"Yes",
"No",
"Maybe"
];
movementOrder = [
"Antifa",
"FFF",
"LG",
"PEGIDA",
"Identitarians",
"Querdenker"
];
movementColors = [
"black",
"green",
"darkorange",
"red",
"gold",
"purple"
];which identity is most emphasised?
m_identity_emphCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_identity_emph", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_identity_emph = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_identity_emphCounts, {
fx: "m_identity_emph",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
// domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -45
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 250,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});which ‘out-group’ is most often part of the group’s narratives
m_outgroupCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_outgroup", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_outgroup = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_outgroupCounts, {
fx: "m_outgroup",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
// domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -45
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 250,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});emotional appeals more important?
m_emotional_appealsCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_emotional_appeals", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_emotional_appeals = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_emotional_appealsCounts, {
fx: "m_emotional_appeals",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: ynmOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: 0
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});positive emotions more important than negative?
m_positive_more_importantCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_positive_more_important", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_positive_more_important = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_positive_more_importantCounts, {
fx: "m_positive_more_important",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -55
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 140,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});which emotion seems most central for the movement?
m_central_emotionCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_central_emotion", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_central_emotion = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_central_emotionCounts, {
fx: "m_central_emotion",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
// domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -45
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 250,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});\(\downarrow\)
Values
Attitudes
Attitudes
Values
Values
Attitudes
Values
Attitudes
Values
Attitudes
values shape attitudes
collective identity is…
Anonymous feedback here: https://forms.gle/AjHt6fcnwZxkSg4X8
Alternatively, please send me an email: m.zeller@lmu.de
Questions about movements next meeting: (1) Which organisational form best describes the movement? (2) Does the movement rely on formal coordination structures (meetings, committees, roles)? (3) Does leadership play a visible and strategic role in guiding the movement? (4) What is the movement’s main strategic orientation? (5) Does the movement mainly use conventional, legally permitted forms of protest? (6) What is the movement’s primary tactic of mobilisation?