Social movements and the media
| Date | Presenters | Method |
|---|---|---|
Where do you get your news?
When you read the news (thinking only of ‘traditional media’ for the moment), what is reported, generally?
What are the mechanisms of…
often it is the media (including social media)
how media covers a movement is often how most people know about it
Take the survey at https://forms.gle/ngepuqqzaFu8nCfBA
Questions about movements: (1) type of media most important for movement’s visibility? (2) movement strategically plans actions to generate media coverage? (3) media coverage of movement generally favourable? (4) audience the movement mainly tries to influence? (5) movement often succeeds in getting its narratives into the media? (6) has the movement influenced public debate?
import { liveGoogleSheet } from "@jimjamslam/live-google-sheet";
import { aq, op } from "@uwdata/arquero";
// UPDATE THE LINK FOR A NEW POLL
surveyResults = liveGoogleSheet(
"https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/" +
"2PACX-1vRFuuWCfyZQLXsybqoVeuOX8eixlnbIKG7xp_W7e9W1FRZNtLl8pMdicFnILQhxM69f1Fn4Hxf_5jG0/" +
"pub?gid=2143204677&single=true&output=csv",
10000, 1, 14); // adjust the last number to select all relevant columns
respondentCount = surveyResults.length;
likertOrder = [
"Strongly disagree",
"Disagree",
"Neutral",
"Agree",
"Strongly agree"
];
ynmOrder = [
"Yes",
"No",
"Maybe"
];
movementOrder = [
"Antifa",
"FFF",
"LG",
"PEGIDA",
"Identitarians",
"Querdenker"
];
movementColors = [
"black",
"green",
"darkorange",
"red",
"gold",
"purple"
];how do media generally portray protesters?
portrayCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.select("portray")
.groupby("portray")
.count()
.derive({ measure: d => "" })
// Calculate the maximum count from your dataset
portray_maxCountRE = Math.max(...portrayCounts.objects().map(d => d.count));
plot_portray = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.barY(portrayCounts, {
x: "portray",
y: "count",
fill: "portray",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.ruleY([respondentCount], { stroke: "#ffffff99" })
],
color: {
domain: [
"dangerous",
"passionate",
"misguided",
"admirable",
"other"
],
range: [
"goldenrod",
"cadetblue",
"darkorange",
"forestgreen",
"violet"
]
},
marginBottom: 400,
x: { label: "", tickSize: 2, tickRotate: -40, padding: 0.2,
domain: ["dangerous", "passionate", "misguided", "admirable", "other"]
},
y: {
label: "",
tickSize: 10,
tickFormat: d => d,
tickValues: Array.from(
new Set(portrayCounts.objects().map(d => d.count))
).sort((a, b) => a - b),
domain: [0, portray_maxCountRE]
},
facet: { data: portrayCounts, x: "measure", label: "" },
marginLeft: 60,
style: {
width: 1600,
height: 500,
fontSize: 40,
},
});most likely to help a movement get media coverage?
help_coverageCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.select("help_coverage")
.groupby("help_coverage")
.count()
.derive({ measure: d => "" })
// Calculate the maximum count from your dataset
help_coverage_maxCountRE = Math.max(...help_coverageCounts.objects().map(d => d.count));
plot_help_coverage = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.barY(help_coverageCounts, {
x: "help_coverage",
y: "count",
fill: "help_coverage",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.ruleY([respondentCount], { stroke: "#ffffff99" })
],
color: {
domain: [
"protest size",
"catchy slogans",
"celebrity support",
"counter-protests",
"disruptiveness/violence",
"topicality (coincidence with other news)",
"other"
],
range: [
"darkred",
"goldenrod",
"cadetblue",
"darkorange",
"forestgreen",
"violet",
"gray"
]
},
marginBottom: 450,
x: { label: "", tickSize: 2, tickRotate: -40, padding: 0.2,
domain: ["protest size", "catchy slogans", "celebrity support", "counter-protests", "disruptiveness/violence", "topicality (coincidence with other news)", "other"]
},
y: {
label: "",
tickSize: 10,
tickFormat: d => d,
tickValues: Array.from(
new Set(help_coverageCounts.objects().map(d => d.count))
).sort((a, b) => a - b),
domain: [0, help_coverage_maxCountRE]
},
facet: { data: help_coverageCounts, x: "measure", label: "" },
marginLeft: 60,
style: {
width: 1600,
height: 500,
fontSize: 40,
},
});should movements tailor their messaging/framing to gain more attention?
tailorCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.select("tailor")
.groupby("tailor")
.count()
.derive({ measure: d => "" })
// Calculate the maximum count from your dataset
tailor_maxCountRE = Math.max(...tailorCounts.objects().map(d => d.count));
plot_tailor = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.barY(tailorCounts, {
x: "tailor",
y: "count",
fill: "tailor",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.ruleY([respondentCount], { stroke: "#ffffff99" })
],
color: {
domain: [
"Strongly disagree",
"Disagree",
"Neutral",
"Agree",
"Strongly agree"
],
range: [
"red",
"pink",
"lightgrey",
"lightgreen",
"forestgreen"
]
},
marginBottom: 180,
x: { label: "", tickSize: 2, tickRotate: -45,
domain: ["Strongly disagree", "Disagree", "Neutral", "Agree", "Strongly agree"]
},
y: {
label: "",
tickSize: 10,
tickFormat: d => d,
tickValues: Array.from(
new Set(tailorCounts.objects().map(d => d.count))
).sort((a, b) => a - b),
domain: [0, tailor_maxCountRE]
},
facet: { data: tailorCounts, x: "measure", label: "" },
marginLeft: 140,
style: {
width: 1350,
height: 500,
fontSize: 30,
}
});is traditional media coverage still necessary for movement success in an age of social media?
traditional_mediaCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.select("traditional_media")
.groupby("traditional_media")
.count()
.derive({ measure: d => "" })
// Calculate the maximum count from your dataset
traditional_media_maxCountRE = Math.max(...traditional_mediaCounts.objects().map(d => d.count));
plot_traditional_media = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.barY(traditional_mediaCounts, {
x: "traditional_media",
y: "count",
fill: "traditional_media",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.ruleY([respondentCount], { stroke: "#ffffff99" })
],
color: {
domain: [
"Strongly disagree",
"Disagree",
"Neutral",
"Agree",
"Strongly agree"
],
range: [
"red",
"pink",
"lightgrey",
"lightgreen",
"forestgreen"
]
},
marginBottom: 180,
x: { label: "", tickSize: 2, tickRotate: -45,
domain: ["Strongly disagree", "Disagree", "Neutral", "Agree", "Strongly agree"]
},
y: {
label: "",
tickSize: 10,
tickFormat: d => d,
tickValues: Array.from(
new Set(traditional_mediaCounts.objects().map(d => d.count))
).sort((a, b) => a - b),
domain: [0, traditional_media_maxCountRE]
},
facet: { data: traditional_mediaCounts, x: "measure", label: "" },
marginLeft: 140,
style: {
width: 1350,
height: 500,
fontSize: 30,
}
});ever personally supported a movement online?
personally_sharedCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.select("personally_shared")
.groupby("personally_shared")
.count()
.derive({ measure: d => "" })
// Calculate the maximum count from your dataset
personally_shared_maxCountRE = Math.max(...personally_sharedCounts.objects().map(d => d.count));
plot_personally_shared = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.barY(personally_sharedCounts, {
x: "personally_shared",
y: "count",
fill: "personally_shared",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.ruleY([respondentCount], { stroke: "#ffffff99" })
],
color: {
domain: [
"Yes",
"No",
"Maybe"
],
range: [
"forestgreen",
"darkred",
"goldenrod"
]
},
marginBottom: 80,
x: { label: "", tickSize: 2, tickRotate: -1, padding: 0.2,
domain: ["Yes", "No", "Maybe"]
},
y: {
label: "",
tickSize: 10,
tickFormat: d => d,
tickValues: Array.from(
new Set(personally_sharedCounts.objects().map(d => d.count))
).sort((a, b) => a - b),
domain: [0, personally_shared_maxCountRE]
},
facet: { data: personally_sharedCounts, x: "measure", label: "" },
marginLeft: 60,
style: {
width: 1600,
height: 500,
fontSize: 40,
},
});does social media encourage ‘slacktivism’?
slacktivismCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.select("slacktivism")
.groupby("slacktivism")
.count()
.derive({ measure: d => "" })
// Calculate the maximum count from your dataset
slacktivism_maxCountRE = Math.max(...slacktivismCounts.objects().map(d => d.count));
plot_slacktivism = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.barY(slacktivismCounts, {
x: "slacktivism",
y: "count",
fill: "slacktivism",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.ruleY([respondentCount], { stroke: "#ffffff99" })
],
color: {
domain: [
"Yes",
"No",
"Maybe"
],
range: [
"forestgreen",
"darkred",
"goldenrod"
]
},
marginBottom: 80,
x: { label: "", tickSize: 2, tickRotate: -1, padding: 0.2,
domain: ["Yes", "No", "Maybe"]
},
y: {
label: "",
tickSize: 10,
tickFormat: d => d,
tickValues: Array.from(
new Set(slacktivismCounts.objects().map(d => d.count))
).sort((a, b) => a - b),
domain: [0, slacktivism_maxCountRE]
},
facet: { data: slacktivismCounts, x: "measure", label: "" },
marginLeft: 60,
style: {
width: 1600,
height: 500,
fontSize: 40,
},
});Data source: Kriesi et al. 2020, PolDem-Protest Dataset 30 European Countries, Version 1. Since PolDem’s events are coded from English-language newswire reports rather than movement or national-press sources. This series is itself a picture of which issues make it into the international media over time, which is useful to pair with the codebook’s discussion of source bias (pp. 9-10, 47-51) when talking about media gatekeeping of movement issues.
Data download
Factors that may affect media coverage
Factors that may affect media coverage
The design of our study is large-N (based on a sample of demonstrations, avoiding the tautology endemic to many studies of media attention to protest, which select cases based on their being reported in the media), at the same time as putting protest in context. (pp. 2293-4)
| Feature | Static | Dynamic |
|---|---|---|
| Number of participants | larger = more coverage | short- and long-term coverage |
| Contentiousness | high = more coverage | short- and long-term coverage |
| Exhibit violence | violence = more coverage | short-term coverage, long-term losses/costs |
| Trigger event | trigger = more coverage | short-term coverage |
do these expectations make sense to you? do you disagree with any?
Remember: regression is a tool for understanding a phenomenon as a linear function (generally) → (y = mx + b)
Numbers not in parentheses next to a variable: regression coefficient: expected change in DV for a one-unit increase in IV. NB: ositive or negative relationship?
Numbers inside parentheses next to a variable: standard error: estimate of the standard deviation of the coefficient
Asterisks/‘stars’: statistical significance: probability of results as extreme as observed result, under the assumption that the null hypothesis is correct. Smaller p-value means such an observation would be less likely under null hypothesis; hence, significance. Statistical significance suggests more precise estimates—NOT necessarily that one IV is more important than another.
type of media most important for the movement?
m_media_for_visibilityCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_media_for_visibility", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_media_for_visibility = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_media_for_visibilityCounts, {
fx: "m_media_for_visibility",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
// domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -45
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 250,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});movement plans actions to generate media coverage?
m_plans_to_generate_attentionCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_plans_to_generate_attention", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_plans_to_generate_attention = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_plans_to_generate_attentionCounts, {
fx: "m_plans_to_generate_attention",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: ynmOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: 0
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 130,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});media coverage of movement generally favourable?
m_favourable_coverageCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_favourable_coverage", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_favourable_coverage = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_favourable_coverageCounts, {
fx: "m_favourable_coverage",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -55
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 140,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});which audience is the movement trying to influence?
m_audience_to_influenceCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_audience_to_influence", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_audience_to_influence = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_audience_to_influenceCounts, {
fx: "m_audience_to_influence",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
// domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -45
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 250,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});movement succeeds in getting its narratives in the media?
m_narratives_into_mediaCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_narratives_into_media", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_narratives_into_media = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_narratives_into_mediaCounts, {
fx: "m_narratives_into_media",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -55
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 140,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});movement has been successful at influencing public debate?
m_succeeds_influencing_debateCounts = aq.from(surveyResults)
.groupby("m_succeeds_influencing_debate", "movement")
.count()
.objects();
plot_m_succeeds_influencing_debate = Plot.plot({
marks: [
Plot.frame({
fill: "#f7f7f7",
stroke: "black",
strokeWidth: 1
}),
Plot.barY(m_succeeds_influencing_debateCounts, {
fx: "m_succeeds_influencing_debate",
x: "movement",
y: "count",
fill: "movement",
stroke: "white"
})
],
color: {
domain: movementOrder,
range: movementColors,
legend: true,
style: { fontSize: "20px" }
},
fx: {
// domain: likertOrder,
label: "",
tickRotate: -45
},
x: {
domain: movementOrder,
axis: null, // clears the entire x-axis (ticks and labels)
// tickFormat: () => "",
label: ""
},
y: {
label: ""
},
marginBottom: 250,
style: {
width: 900,
height: 500,
fontSize: 20
}
});(USA Today on BLM)
(USA Today on BLM)
social media breaks down traditional media gatekeeper roles
Class 4: we listened to Tufecki and social media mobilisation and ‘old-school organisation’ - can attract more participants, but perhaps with less commitment
1929, Easter Sunday Parade: a Tabubruch? more emancipation for women?
astroturfing - manipulation of public sphere (media, information, movement scene)
see further, on the theory: Herman, E. S., & Chomsky, N. (1988). Manufacturing consent: The political economy of the mass media. Random House.
Anonymous feedback here: https://forms.gle/AjHt6fcnwZxkSg4X8
Alternatively, please send me an email: m.zeller@lmu.de
Questions about movements next meeting: (1) Is coalition with other movements important for this movement’s success? (2) movement participated in broad “umbrella coalitions”? (3) Are coalition partners seen as temporary allies rather than long-term partners? (4) Do coalition actions tend to be more effective for the movement? (5) Are the movement’s coalitions are primarily local rather than national or international? (6) Does the movement have supportive allies in one or more political party?
Social movements and social media